Opinion Needed: No Negative Voting
IITDU Forum :: General :: IITDU Blog
Page 1 of 1
20110111
Opinion Needed: No Negative Voting
Let me clarify.
From the start of voting system, the negative vote has been abused many times.
Sometimes people used it on another because of simple mistakes. Even if they corrected it, as the voting is irreversible, they still had that negative vote. Sometimes negative vote was given because of personal issues.
Now, consider this as a scenario.
At IITDU forum, only positive vote button becomes visible. The negative one is thrown away.
Will you like it?
There are some advantages obviously. Because the negative vote button was abused, we had to make a rule like no voting for people with less than 5 reputation. We won't need that.
We can give negative feedbacks, and if the user improves himself, we can give positive vote, etc etc.
And besides, we rarely even use the negative vote button. The voting should be used to encourage people to contribute here even more, not discourage them at the slightest mistakes.
lets hear about this matter from you.
From the start of voting system, the negative vote has been abused many times.
Sometimes people used it on another because of simple mistakes. Even if they corrected it, as the voting is irreversible, they still had that negative vote. Sometimes negative vote was given because of personal issues.
Now, consider this as a scenario.
At IITDU forum, only positive vote button becomes visible. The negative one is thrown away.
Will you like it?
There are some advantages obviously. Because the negative vote button was abused, we had to make a rule like no voting for people with less than 5 reputation. We won't need that.
We can give negative feedbacks, and if the user improves himself, we can give positive vote, etc etc.
And besides, we rarely even use the negative vote button. The voting should be used to encourage people to contribute here even more, not discourage them at the slightest mistakes.
lets hear about this matter from you.
Opinion Needed: No Negative Voting :: Comments
নাহ ...তার আগে তাইলে আমার নেগেটিভ ভোটগুলা পজিটিভ করে দেওয়া হোক..........
Last edited by BIT0112-Rokon on Tue Jan 11, 2011 11:53 pm; edited 1 time in total
Last edited by BIT0112-Rokon on Tue Jan 11, 2011 11:53 pm; edited 1 time in total
আরে আজব এটা যে করা যায় তাই আজকে জানলাম।
আর সবচাইতে বেশি নেগেটিভ ভোট তো আমি খাইছি
আমার তো ওগুলো নিয়ে মাথা ব্যাথা নাই।
আর সবচাইতে বেশি নেগেটিভ ভোট তো আমি খাইছি
আমার তো ওগুলো নিয়ে মাথা ব্যাথা নাই।
আরে না রে ভাই :S এটা আমার সাথে সম্পর্কিত না।
সবাই খালি আমাকে খোচায় কেন :S :S কেউ তো বলতেসেই না এটা করা উচিত নাকি না।
সবাই খালি আমাকে খোচায় কেন :S :S কেউ তো বলতেসেই না এটা করা উচিত নাকি না।
BIT0103-Ovid wrote:অমিত আমার কাছে নেগেটিভ ভোট খাইয়া এই অবস্থা
আমারও মনে হয় নেগেটিভ ভোটটা বাদ দেয়া যায়।
পসিটিভ ভোট উৎসাহ দেয় কিন্তু নেগেটিভ ভোট খুব একটা উপকার করেনা
তাছাড়া ব্যক্তিগত আক্রোশ থেকেও অনেক সময় দেয়া হয়।
আর আলিমের মতন experiment তো আছেই
My opinion is, remove the voting system. I dont know why it was introduced.
You should've mentioned that opinion in wishlist.
And I think majority will say that voting should be kept. That's my opinion though. If you decide that voting is no longer necessary, it can be deactivated
But considering that this is a topic regarding negative votes issue only, I would like to know your opinion.
And I think majority will say that voting should be kept. That's my opinion though. If you decide that voting is no longer necessary, it can be deactivated
But considering that this is a topic regarding negative votes issue only, I would like to know your opinion.
BIT0102-Mohaimin wrote:My opinion is, remove the voting system. I don't know why it was introduced.
vai, do you know , somebody has great attraction to our forum only for this voting system.And they post anything they know here.And that good.When you remove the voting system all these enthusiasm will be lost and at the same time you,I and all the members of our forum will be in a great loss. So,removing the voting system might not be a good idea at all.
My opinion is to remove only the negative voting.That may be the better option.
I'm actually confused to what use voting comes?
But there are many cases where someone deserves a reputation/acceptance of his nice/helpful/urgent/brilliant/useful post.
And I believe negative voting has been put in fewer occasions. Even though I haven't got one yet, I don't think it'll be too encouraging for me.
Everyone posts within his/her merit. To criticize it is fair enough to me.
So if voting stays, then positive voting must stay. Negative voting can only stay if forum members think that there is more left to do than to criticize.
But there are many cases where someone deserves a reputation/acceptance of his nice/helpful/urgent/brilliant/useful post.
And I believe negative voting has been put in fewer occasions. Even though I haven't got one yet, I don't think it'll be too encouraging for me.
Everyone posts within his/her merit. To criticize it is fair enough to me.
So if voting stays, then positive voting must stay. Negative voting can only stay if forum members think that there is more left to do than to criticize.
It is implemented. The minimum number of reputation to give someone a positive vote is back to 0 now.
Means anyone can participate in voting
Also, the icon has been changed. Instead of +, the thumbs up is more meaningful.
Means anyone can participate in voting
Also, the icon has been changed. Instead of +, the thumbs up is more meaningful.
I don't like the thumb's up icon.
It seems like a head of a toothbrush to me.
Asking for vote to change the icon and put a good one.
It seems like a head of a toothbrush to me.
Asking for vote to change the icon and put a good one.
[You must be registered and logged in to see this image.] ইচ্ছে তালিকাতে এসব বলার অনুরোধ রইল।
আর সাথে কি ধরনের icon দিলে ভালো হয় তা বললে আমাদের জন্য সুবিধা হয়।
কারণ আমরা কিছু পরিবর্তন করে দিলে সেটা দেই প্রাথমিকভাবে যেটা দেখতে আমাদের কাছে সব চাইতে ভালো লাগে।
edit:
It is locked. If you have an suggestion, please refer to Wishlist.
আর সাথে কি ধরনের icon দিলে ভালো হয় তা বললে আমাদের জন্য সুবিধা হয়।
কারণ আমরা কিছু পরিবর্তন করে দিলে সেটা দেই প্রাথমিকভাবে যেটা দেখতে আমাদের কাছে সব চাইতে ভালো লাগে।
edit:
It is locked. If you have an suggestion, please refer to Wishlist.
Similar topics
» Opinion needed : which one is looking better ?
» Opinion needed : chatting in Forum - Default or IRC?
» Topic Title icons: User feedback needed
» JSDK needed
» Java Help needed: Problem with using graphics
» Opinion needed : chatting in Forum - Default or IRC?
» Topic Title icons: User feedback needed
» JSDK needed
» Java Help needed: Problem with using graphics
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
|
|
Tue Sep 29, 2015 2:45 pm by Sophiawood
» Cisco EHWIC SFP/GE WAN Card
Mon Sep 07, 2015 11:08 am by Sophiawood
» Huawei S1700-28GFR-4P-AC Price
Thu Jun 25, 2015 2:31 pm by Sophiawood
» teach yourself C++ / Herbert Schildt Solutions
Wed Jun 03, 2015 1:52 pm by Abdullah Al Noman
» teach yourself c by herbert schildt pdf
Wed May 13, 2015 11:01 pm by Raquib Ridwan
» ASA 5506X With Firepower ASA5506-K9
Fri Apr 10, 2015 4:31 pm by Sophiawood
» New Trends in Deal Business
Tue Feb 03, 2015 9:38 pm by nersoa
» PoE Power Allocation for WS-C2960S-24PS-L
Wed Nov 05, 2014 11:12 am by Sophiawood
» How to cure back pain
Fri Oct 31, 2014 7:15 pm by Bergen Guildford